I like that show where they solve all the murd3rs ([info]cedarlibrarian) wrote,
  • Mood: cranky

To the blogger go the spoilers

Since everyone else is doing it...

I guess I'm the second-worst kind of Harry Potter fan there is, because I read this Washington Post article on spoilers for the books and thought, "You know what? I don't care."

I will have my cell phone on, as always, all weekend as I read. I will be online looking for people to discuss the book with. I don't care if someone driving down 18th Street at 12:05 a.m. yells out the ending of Deathly Hallows from the window of his car. I don't care if someone who steals a copy of the book early walks in front of me wearing a t-shirt pronouncing all the deaths in the book before the release. I am not creating a spoiler-free filter for this journal (though I am not so inconsiderate as to not cut them for a week). I won't be locking entries in which I discuss the book.

Why? Because for me it's about the journey, not the destination.

Let's say Harry dies. I don't know if this will happen, though given the following of the hero's journey tale it's unlikely. But let's say it does. If you want to flip to the end of the book and yell at me, "Hey, Cedar, Harry dies!" you won't get much more than a shrug and an "Oh, really? Okay." To me, it's not about the events of the book, but how we get there. I want to see the process and the battles and the build to the turning events. I want to read all the dialogue and see the alliances and betrayals unfold. I care more about HOW Lucius Malfoy gets out of Azkaban than whether he does or not. So unless you plan to sit in front of me and read the book aloud cover to cover (which I actually wouldn't mind too much, as I love being read to), you're not going to upset me by posting anything about the events of HP&tDH. I am not so fragile as to be upset over the events, or lack thereof, of a book. When you listen to a sports report, you want to hear more than something like "Cubs won, Sox lost." You want to hear about the major plays, the good calls, the questionable calls, etc. It's about how the game got to those final scores, not just about who won or lost. (And really, by the time someone got around to tell me all the spoilers I wanted to hear, told me about the processes that truly interest me, I'd be done with the book because I read pretty fast.)

Feel free to put me on all your spoiler and discussion filters, if you're making them. Spoiler-free people, to me, are like people who drink pulp-free orange juice. It's totally fine for them and I'm glad pulp-free orange juice exists so no one has to be denied their vitamin C goodness. But I want my orange juice to be practically chewable.

(Although I WILL become angry if we never find out why Peter Pettigrew betrayed the Potters. I still don't trust Sirius's explanation of "Peter was weak" any further than I can throw it.)

Alice In Chains - I Stay Away
Tags: harry potter

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 14 comments

[info]buymeaclue

July 8 2007, 19:21:10 UTC 4 years ago

Hallelujah!

[info]darththalia

July 8 2007, 19:26:24 UTC 4 years ago

When you listen to a sports report, you want to hear more than something like "Cubs won, Sox lost."

No, actually, I'm pretty happy with those results. [g]

[info]cedarlibrarian

July 8 2007, 19:27:25 UTC 4 years ago

Chicago sports fans are silly people. *tickles*

[info]titti

July 8 2007, 19:37:47 UTC 4 years ago

I agree with you 100%. I'm a little more careful with TV show because nowadays you get full transcripts and not just a few spoilers, but with a book, I really don't care. In fact I love spoilers for the book because one I'm not rushing to get to learn that information I can enjoy the details a lot more.

[info]janni

July 8 2007, 19:41:35 UTC 4 years ago

I think there's something a little ... well, childish about focusing on who lives and who dies. As if the story were just a sports came, and not just a story.

That said, if Hermione is the only person left standing when the dust clears, I won't mourn much. :-)

[info]cedarlibrarian

July 8 2007, 19:44:58 UTC 4 years ago

Replace "Hermione" in your last sentence with "Ron and Professor McGonagall" and I'm with you all the way.

[info]janni

July 8 2007, 19:46:40 UTC 4 years ago

I'll go halfway with you and agree to saving Professor McGonagall's life. :-)

Hmmm, maybe the question shouldn't be who dies, but who we're willing to let live ...

[info]rfachir

July 8 2007, 19:59:00 UTC 4 years ago

Isn't there a spoiler that McGonagall is really Evil and Wicked, and will emerge as the Last Witch Standing after she reveals herself as the True Dark Lord and renames herself Elphaba? (All Dark Lords need cool new names and noses.)

[info]janni

July 8 2007, 21:08:59 UTC 4 years ago

Oh, that happened back in book 5, only everyone was so busy paying attention to all the Quidditch they didn't notice. :-)

[info]purpleink

July 8 2007, 20:23:40 UTC 4 years ago

Ditto. To everything you said. :)

*stands in line behind you to discuss and happily be spoiled*

[info]ceilidh

July 8 2007, 22:49:38 UTC 4 years ago

*dittos*!!

[info]endofhistory

July 9 2007, 02:47:23 UTC 4 years ago

I LOVE PULPY ORANGE JUICE!

[info]cedarlibrarian

July 9 2007, 03:26:08 UTC 4 years ago

WHICH IS WHY YOU SHOULD COME VISIT ME! WE CAN HAVE EXTRA-PULPY ORANGE JUICE AND REALLY GOOD BAGELS AND THEN GO TO LUSH.

[info]ex_fastertha931

July 9 2007, 11:55:23 UTC 4 years ago

Bwahahaha! Oh, how I heart you.

I'm doing my chapter-a-day thingie one last time, so I'm probably not going to actively seek out spoilers or read much media. But otherwise, I'm right there with you. They can't really spoil "who," only "how," and "how" takes so long to explain, I could run far away before they got the first sentence out. ;)

This is gonna be so much freaking fun...
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…